articles

Feb. 9th National Pizza Day: Sussex County's Best Pizza

There's a lot of competition for best pizza in Sussex County, but here are some of your favorites

By Macaroni KID Sussex, Melissa Leon February 5, 2024

Oh, pizza. How we adore you! Whether it's a busy weeknight or a lazy weekend, pizza always comes to the rescue. Plus, who can resist that heavenly combination of melted cheese, savory toppings, and a perfectly crispy crust? We certainly can't!

🍕 Pass me another slice, please. Don't forget to contact your favorite pizza place to see about their heart-shaped pizza for Valentine's Day!

We are incredibly fortunate to have a number of fantastic locally-owned pizza joints right here in Sussex County, ready to satisfy our every pizza craving. Join us on a mouthwatering journey through your top picks for the best pizza in Sussex County:

1. Newton Pizza 

📍 Address: 274 Lower Spring Street, Newton, NJ

📞 Phone:973-383-6525



 Artes Graficas Collective | Canva

2. Pizza One 

📍 Address: 12 North Village Blvd. Sparta, NJ

📞 Phone: 973-862-4933


3. Frank's Pizza Wantage

📍 Address: 205 Rt-23 Wantage, NJ 

📞 Phone: 973-875-1250



 Riedelmeier | Canva

4. Tomato Garden Pizza Restaurant 

📍 Address:530 County Road 515, Vernon 

📞 Phone: 973-764-4162


5. Lorenzo's 

📍 Address: 67 Main Street, Sussex 

📞 Phone: 973-875-5055


6. Camisa Pizza  

📍 Address: 129 Decker Pond Road, Tranquility

📞 Phone: 973-786-4123


7. Tony's Restaurant Pizza & Pub 

📍 Address: 2771 RT-23, Stockholm 

📞 Phone: 973-697-5680


8. Firehouse Pizza  

📍 Address: 152 Main Street, Andover 

📞 Phone: 973-786-0001


9. Anthony Francos Restaurant & Pizzeria  

📍 Address: 8 Town Center Dr., Sparta  

📞 Phone: 973-729-6000